benlehman

Who's been commenting in your journal?

1	benlehman		150 comments	28.96% of total
2	relevance		35 comments	6.76% of total
3	wirednavi		23 comments	4.44% of total
4	matt_rah		23 comments	4.44% of total
5	rich_forest		20 comments	3.86% of total
6	funwithrage		19 comments	3.67% of total
7	taranhero		18 comments	3.47% of total
8	silvergoose		17 comments	3.28% of total
9	evilmagnus		15 comments	2.9% of total
10	xiombarg		14 comments	2.7% of total
11	arianhwyvar		13 comments	2.51% of total
12	psychotropek		13 comments	2.51% of total
13	unrequitedthai		12 comments	2.32% of total
14	Anonymous		9 comments	1.74% of total
15	bicoastal		9 comments	1.74% of total
16	emergent		8 comments	1.54% of total
17	greywords		7 comments	1.35% of total
18	meiganren		7 comments	1.35% of total
19	conspiratrix		7 comments	1.35% of total
20	marcus_sez_vote		6 comments	1.16% of total
21	dj_clawson		6 comments	1.16% of total
22	russiandude		6 comments	1.16% of total
23	timeritual		6 comments	1.16% of total
24	redcrosse		5 comments	0.97% of total
25	fructivore		5 comments	0.97% of total
26	foreign_devilry		5 comments	0.97% of total
27	bigbluebackpack		5 comments	0.97% of total
28	shatterdaymorn		5 comments	0.97% of total
29	mazarin		4 comments	0.77% of total
30	chrislehrich		4 comments	0.77% of total
31	locke61dv		4 comments	0.77% of total
32	thestealthyone		3 comments	0.58% of total
33	denyse		3 comments	0.58% of total
34	damidnara		3 comments	0.58% of total
35	crnixon		3 comments	0.58% of total
36	noradannan		3 comments	0.58% of total
37	salda007		3 comments	0.58% of total
38	egowumpus		2 comments	0.39% of total
39	kiddens		2 comments	0.39% of total
40	iralith		2 comments	0.39% of total
41	gesturejester		2 comments	0.39% of total
42	goofnose		2 comments	0.39% of total
43	apollinax		1 comments	0.19% of total
44	labyrinth_ghoul		1 comments	0.19% of total
45	lumpley		1 comments	0.19% of total
46	w0lfstar		1 comments	0.19% of total
47	aumshantih		1 comments	0.19% of total
48	ornithoptercat		1 comments	0.19% of total
49	wheeloffire		1 comments	0.19% of total
50	greymalkin42		1 comments	0.19% of total
51	heyunyi		1 comments	0.19% of total
52	protagoras		1 comments	0.19% of total

These statistics were generated using the LJ Stats Web Interface by mpnolan. Original idea from scrapdog's LJ Comment Stats Wizard.

Eric Burns is my hero. For many reasons, really.

But especially for this.

If you are angry at them, read it. For any value of them.

http://www.websnark.com/archives/2005/01/the_twelfth_com.html#comments

This is an RPG design post. It isn't a Forge post simply because it isn't focused enough to be. You have been warned.

As Vincent points out, we have the whole form of conflict resolution and resolution mechanics in general pretty much down. This is a monumental amount of work over a monumental amount of time, originating in the murky depths of the 80s and carrying through until the present day games of Dogs, HeroQuest, and Primetime Adventures. There is still a lot of work to be done, of course, but now we can classify it and really make it work.

But that doesn't mean that RPG design is done, or that it is all about refining conflict resolution mechanisms.

I want to talk about something else. I want to talk about non-conflict, non-task mechanism.

It is a sign of how hideously underdeveloped these mechanics and the theory surrounding them is that I cannot think of anything to say about these sorts of mechanics. RPG theorists (and here I am using a broad category) have, for a very long time, reducing RPG systems into their resolution systems (whether conflict or task resolution isn't really important to this point) and dismissed other aspects of RPG system as unnecessary cruft, or simply didn't recognize their existence entirely.

And I think it is time that we start to analyze them.

Here are some examples:
The chart in Polaris, and it's predecessor diagram in Sorcerer.
The Random Dungeon generation tables of AD&D1
The direct "use this game for this" instructions
Town generation in D&D3, and its predecessors in Spelljammer system generation charts and Thief's Handbook guild and city generation rules
Oriental Adventures (1st) random events charts
non-combat movement and maneuvering rules, including travel but also swimmingly, climbing and flight.

How can we categorize these things? How can we study them? How can we make them more graceful? How can we make them more fun?

Right now we are groping in the dark. We have no idea what these things mean. We throw them together, and see if they stick. Sometimes they are awesome, sometimes they aren't, but there is no understanding, yet. We are monkeys with typewriters.

Anyone want to start?